Swizec Teller - a geek with a hatswizec.com

    Checking for primes? Dumber algorithm is faster algorithm

    It's been a busy few weeks since I last posted about my toying around with project euler, but never you mind. I did do some progress nontheless! HA!

    Just so I won't bore you with the details, the most interesting thing I discovered is that the way I was calculating prime numbers was totally wrong. Not in the sense that it didn't work, but in the sense that it was only fast in theory. In practice it turns out that either my implementation was completely and utterly horrible or that I simply don't know enough about performance bottlenecks of clojure and made a boo boo somewhere.

    Here's my original way of creating prime numbers and checking if a number is prime:

    (defn any? [l]
    (reduce #(or %1 %2) l))
    (defn prime? [n known]
    (loop [cnt (dec (count known)) acc []]
    (if (< cnt 0) (not (any? acc))
    (recur (dec cnt) (concat acc [(zero? (mod n (nth known cnt)))])))))
    (defn next-prime [primes]
    (let [n (inc (count primes))]
    (let [lk (if (even? (inc (last primes))) (+ 2 (last primes)) (inc (last primes)))]
    (loop [cnt lk p primes]
    (if (>= (count p) n) (last p)
    (recur (+ cnt 2) (if (prime? cnt p) (concat p [cnt]) p)))))))
    (defn n-primes [n]
    (loop [cnt 1 p [2]]
    (if (>= cnt n) p
    (recur (inc cnt) (concat p [(next-prime p)])))))

    Not exactly certain what sieve I was using here, but the idea is that a number is prime if it isn't divisible by any primes smaller than the number you're checking. This works great in theory because you're always dividing with very few numbers.

    But turns out, there's a much much faster way of doing it:

    (defn any? [l]
    (reduce #(or %1 %2) l))
    (defn prime? [n]
    (if (even? n) false
    (let [root (num (int (Math/sqrt n)))]
    (loop [i 3]
    (if (> i root) true
    (if (zero? (mod n i)) false
    (recur (+ i 2))))))))
    (defn n-primes [n]
    (loop [num 2 p []]
    (if (>= (count p) n) p
    (recur (inc num) (if (prime? num) (concat p [num]) p)))))

    This way of checking for primes just loops through all numbers smaller than the square root of the one we're checking by starting off with 3 and jumping by two places.

    Obviously a very big improvement here is using the square root as the looping boundary, but turns out even adding this trick to the previous method only goes so far. The dumber version is still at least a 100 times faster. In fact the dumb version produced all primes under 2,000,000 in about a minute whereas the first version wasn't even finished after ten minutes.

    So what's happening here? Considering the sparseness of prime number distribution I'm thinking that the dumber method performed at least ten times more divisions.

    My theory is that maybe, just maybe, the problem was in copying that huge arse list of known primes around when performing function calls. Or maybe it was the appending of primes to the big list that was the problem ... whatever it was, I learned a valuable lesson: Keep it Stupid Simple For Realz.

    Enhanced by Zemanta

    Did you enjoy this article?

    Published on March 21st, 2011 in Clojure, Computer Science, Math, Prime number, Technical

    Learned something new?
    Want to become an expert?

    Here's how it works 👇

    Leave your email and I'll send you thoughtfully written emails every week about React, JavaScript, and your career. Lessons learned over 20 years in the industry working with companies ranging from tiny startups to Fortune5 behemoths.

    Join Swizec's Newsletter

    And get thoughtful letters 💌 on mindsets, tactics, and technical skills for your career. Real lessons from building production software. No bullshit.

    "Man, love your simple writing! Yours is the only newsletter I open and only blog that I give a fuck to read & scroll till the end. And wow always take away lessons with me. Inspiring! And very relatable. 👌"

    ~ Ashish Kumar

    Join over 14,000 engineers just like you already improving their careers with my letters, workshops, courses, and talks. ✌️

    Have a burning question that you think I can answer? I don't have all of the answers, but I have some! Hit me up on twitter or book a 30min ama for in-depth help.

    Ready to Stop copy pasting D3 examples and create data visualizations of your own?  Learn how to build scalable dataviz components your whole team can understand with React for Data Visualization

    Curious about Serverless and the modern backend? Check out Serverless Handbook, modern backend for the frontend engineer.

    Ready to learn how it all fits together and build a modern webapp from scratch? Learn how to launch a webapp and make your first 💰 on the side with ServerlessReact.Dev

    Want to brush up on your modern JavaScript syntax? Check out my interactive cheatsheet: es6cheatsheet.com

    By the way, just in case no one has told you it yet today: I love and appreciate you for who you are ❤️

    Created by Swizec with ❤️